Journal of Pathology and Translational Medicine

Original Article

Interobserver Variability in Diagnosing High-Grade Neuroendocrine Carcinoma of the Lung and Comparing It with the Morphometric Analysis: Seung Yeon Ha, Joungho Han, Wan-Seop Kim, Byung Seong Suh, Mee Sook Roh; Korean J Pathol. 2012;46(1):42-47. Published online February 23, 2012; DOI: https://doi.org/10.4132/KoreanJPathol.2012.46.1.42

7,223 View
44 Download
19 Crossref

Background

Distinguishing small cell lung carcinoma (SCLC) and large cell neuroendocrine carcinoma (LCNEC) of the lung is difficult with little information about interobserver variability.

Methods

One hundred twenty-nine cases of resected SCLC and LCNEC were independently evaluated by four pathologists and classified according to the 2004 World Health Organization criteria. Agreement was regarded as "unanimous" if all four pathologists agreed on the classification. The kappa statistic was calculated to measure the degree of agreement between pathologists. We also measured cell size using image analysis, and receiver-operating-characteristic curve analysis was performed to evaluate cell size in predicting the diagnosis of high-grade neuroendocrine (NE) carcinomas in 66 cases.

Results

Unanimous agreement was achieved in 55.0% of 129 cases. The kappa values ranged from 0.35 to 0.81. Morphometric analysis reaffirmed that there was a continuous spectrum of cell size from SCLC to LCNEC and showed that tumors with cells falling in the middle size range were difficult to categorize and lacked unanimous agreement.

Conclusions

Our results provide an objective explanation for considerable interobserver variability in the diagnosis of high-grade pulmonary NE carcinomas. Further studies would need to define more stringent and objective definitions of cytologic and architectural characteristics to reliably distinguish between SCLC and LCNEC.

Citations

Citations to this article as recorded by

Updates on lung neuroendocrine neoplasm classification
Giulia Vocino Trucco, Luisella Righi, Marco Volante, Mauro Papotti
Histopathology.2024; 84(1): 67. CrossRef
Recent advancement of HDAC inhibitors against breast cancer
Syed Abdulla Mehmood, Kantrol Kumar Sahu, Sounok Sengupta, Sangh Partap, Rajshekhar Karpoormath, Brajesh Kumar, Deepak Kumar
Medical Oncology.2023;[Epub] CrossRef
Genomic Feature of a Rare Case of Mix Small-Cell and Large-Cell Neuroendocrine Lung Carcinoma: A Case Report
Youcai Zhu, Feng Zhang, Dong Yu, Fang Wang, Manxiang Yin, Liangye Chen, Chun Xiao, Yueyan Huang, Feng Ding
Frontiers in Oncology.2022;[Epub] CrossRef
Small-Cell Carcinoma of the Lung: What We Learned about It?
Luisella Righi, Marco Volante, Mauro Papotti
Acta Cytologica.2022; 66(4): 257. CrossRef
Hierarchical identification of a transcriptional panel for the histological diagnosis of lung neuroendocrine tumors
Juxuan Zhang, Jiaxing Deng, Xiao Feng, Yilong Tan, Xin Li, Yixin Liu, Mengyue Li, Haitao Qi, Lefan Tang, Qingwei Meng, Haidan Yan, Lishuang Qi
Frontiers in Genetics.2022;[Epub] CrossRef
Immunohistochemical Staining With Neuroendocrine Markers is Essential in the Diagnosis of Neuroendocrine Neoplasms of the Esophagogastric Junction
Dea N.M. Jepsen, Anne-Marie K. Fiehn, Rajendra S. Garbyal, Ulla Engel, Jakob Holm, Birgitte Federspiel
Applied Immunohistochemistry & Molecular Morphology.2021; 29(6): 454. CrossRef
Improving differential diagnosis of pulmonary large cell neuroendocrine carcinoma and small cell lung cancer via a transcriptomic, biological pathway-based machine learning model
Junhong Guo, Likun Hou, Wei Zhang, Zhengwei Dong, Lei Zhang, Chunyan Wu
Translational Oncology.2021; 14(12): 101222. CrossRef
Are neuroendocrine negative small cell lung cancer and large cell neuroendocrine carcinoma with WT RB1 two faces of the same entity?
Dmitriy Sonkin, Anish Thomas, Beverly A Teicher
Lung Cancer Management.2019; 8(2): LMT13. CrossRef
Ki-67 labeling index of neuroendocrine tumors of the lung has a high level of correspondence between biopsy samples and surgical specimens when strict counting guidelines are applied
Alessandra Fabbri, Mara Cossa, Angelica Sonzogni, Mauro Papotti, Luisella Righi, Gaia Gatti, Patrick Maisonneuve, Barbara Valeri, Ugo Pastorino, Giuseppe Pelosi
Virchows Archiv.2017; 470(2): 153. CrossRef
The Use of Immunohistochemistry Improves the Diagnosis of Small Cell Lung Cancer and Its Differential Diagnosis. An International Reproducibility Study in a Demanding Set of Cases
Erik Thunnissen, Alain C. Borczuk, Douglas B. Flieder, Birgit Witte, Mary Beth Beasley, Jin-Haeng Chung, Sanja Dacic, Sylvie Lantuejoul, Prudence A. Russell, Michael den Bakker, Johan Botling, Elisabeth Brambilla, Erienne de Cuba, Kim R. Geisinger, Kenzo
Journal of Thoracic Oncology.2017; 12(2): 334. CrossRef
Reply to Letter “The Use of Immunohistochemistry Improves the Diagnosis of Small Cell Lung Cancer and Its Differential Diagnosis. An International Reproducibility Study in a Demanding Set of Cases.”
Erik Thunnissen, Birgit I. Witte, Masayuki Noguchi, Yasushi Yatabe
Journal of Thoracic Oncology.2017; 12(6): e70. CrossRef
What clinicians are asking pathologists when dealing with lung neuroendocrine neoplasms?
Giuseppe Pelosi, Alessandra Fabbri, Mara Cossa, Angelica Sonzogni, Barbara Valeri, Luisella Righi, Mauro Papotti
Seminars in Diagnostic Pathology.2015; 32(6): 469. CrossRef
Unraveling Tumor Grading and Genomic Landscape in Lung Neuroendocrine Tumors
Giuseppe Pelosi, Mauro Papotti, Guido Rindi, Aldo Scarpa
Endocrine Pathology.2014; 25(2): 151. CrossRef
Grading the neuroendocrine tumors of the lung: an evidence-based proposal
G Rindi, C Klersy, F Inzani, G Fellegara, L Ampollini, A Ardizzoni, N Campanini, P Carbognani, T M De Pas, D Galetta, P L Granone, L Righi, M Rusca, L Spaggiari, M Tiseo, G Viale, M Volante, M Papotti, G Pelosi
Endocrine-Related Cancer.2014; 21(1): 1. CrossRef
Controversial issues and new discoveries in lung neuroendocrine tumors
Giuseppe Pelosi, Kenzo Hiroshima, Mari Mino-Kenudson
Diagnostic Histopathology.2014; 20(10): 392. CrossRef
BAI3, CDX2 and VIL1: a panel of three antibodies to distinguish small cell from large cell neuroendocrine lung carcinomas
Muhammad F Bari, Helen Brown, Andrew G Nicholson, Keith M Kerr, John R Gosney, William A Wallace, Irshad Soomro, Salli Muller, Danielle Peat, Jonathan D Moore, Lesley A Ward, Maxim B Freidin, Eric Lim, Manu Vatish, David R J Snead
Histopathology.2014; 64(4): 547. CrossRef
Neuroendocrine tumours—challenges in the diagnosis and classification of pulmonary neuroendocrine tumours
M A den Bakker, F B J M Thunnissen
Journal of Clinical Pathology.2013; 66(10): 862. CrossRef
Morphologic Analysis of Pulmonary Neuroendocrine Tumors
Seung Seok Lee, Myunghee Kang, Seung Yeon Ha, Jungsuk An, Mee Sook Roh, Chang Won Ha, Jungho Han
Korean Journal of Pathology.2013; 47(1): 16. CrossRef
Altered expression of microRNA miR‐21, miR‐155, and let‐7a and their roles in pulmonary neuroendocrine tumors
Hyoun Wook Lee, Eun Hee Lee, Seung Yeon Ha, Chang Hun Lee, Hee Kyung Chang, Sunhee Chang, Kun Young Kwon, Il Seon Hwang, Mee Sook Roh, Jeong Wook Seo
Pathology International.2012; 62(9): 583. CrossRef

First
Prev
Page of 1
Next
Last

Search